American League:

1B – Konerko, Paul
2B – Cano, Robinson
SS – Cabrera, Asdrubal
3B – Rodriguez, Alex
C – Avila, Alex
DH – Ortiz, David
OF – Bautista, Jose
OF – Ellsbury, Jacoby
OF – Hamilton, Josh
Write-in – N/A
National League:

1B – Fielder, Prince
2B – Weeks, Rickie
SS – Reyes, Jose
3B – Ramirez, Aramis
C – McCann, Brian
OF – Berkman, Lance
OF – Braun, Ryan
OF – Kemp, Matt
Write-in – N/A